Category
Ice Makers
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning,…
101+
Reviews
2026
Updated
100%
Honest
All
Top Rated
Newest
A to Z
1
8.7
Igloo 5-Gallon Party Ice Bin: best overall with 8+ hour ice retention and drain spigot.
Coleman Party Bin: best value with similar insulation and a lower price.
Rubbermaid Commercial 5-Gallon: best budget option for dry ice or short events.
2
9.0
Quiet motor and stainless steel blade produce fluffy snow cone ice.
Easy to disassemble for cleaning; shaving head and tray are dishwasher safe.
Compact design fits under cabinets; rubber feet prevent slipping.
3
8.7
Natural soapstone cubes chill without dilution or aftertaste
Reusable and easy to clean with mild soap
Includes wooden tray for stylish storage
Scotsman Prodigy Plus C0630MA-1: 356 lbs/day, antimicrobial, self-diagnostics.
Manitowoc NX0610A-161: 310 lbs/day, self-cleaning cycle, reliable.
EdgeStar CWB-322S: 322 lbs/day, budget-friendly, compact.
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Nugget ice from GE Opal 2.0 is soft and chewable, similar to Sonic ice.
Frigidaire 50 lb produces bullet ice at 50 lb/day, fastest in this comparison.
Costway 26 lb is the most affordable, but bin capacity is only 1.5 lb.
8
8.8
Granular activated carbon for chlorine taste and odor
Quarter-inch fittings match fridge and ice maker lines
About one year of rated service per filter
GE Profile Opal: best for nugget ice, self-cleaning, WiFi
Frigidaire EFIC108: best value, 48 lbs/day, side reservoir
Silonn Slim: budget pick, 26 lbs/day, compact
App or physical remote control for convenient ice production.
Nugget or bullet ice options to suit different preferences.
Self-cleaning cycles and removable parts for easy maintenance.
Ice Makers Buying Guide
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning, with honest notes on what these machines can and cannot do.