The GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the best ice maker for a counter depth fridge because its compact footprint (11.3 x 11.3 x 13.5 inches) fits neatly on a standard counter, and it produces nugget ice quickly without requiring a water line. For those seeking a simpler, more affordable option, the Frigidaire EFIC235 is a solid value. For strict budgets, the Costway 26 lbs unit delivers decent ice at a low price. Avoid the Igloo ICEB26HN because its ice basket is too wide for many counter depth setups.

Quick Answer

Best overall for compact size and nugget ice quality. Best value for reliable bullet ice with simple controls. Best budget for basic ice needs. Avoid the Igloo ICEB26HN due to basket width issues.

  • Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0: nugget ice, compact, no drain needed
  • Best value: Frigidaire EFIC235: quiet, 26 lbs/day, easy cleaning
  • Best budget: Costway 26 lbs: affordable, small footprint, manual fill
  • Avoid: Igloo ICEB26HN: basket too wide, ice melts quickly

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.

Quick Picks

  • Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0, Nugget ice maker with compact design, self-cleaning, and side tank.. Check price on Amazon
  • Best value: Frigidaire EFIC235, Reliable bullet ice maker with quiet operation and simple controls..
  • Best budget: Costway 26 lbs, Budget-friendly countertop unit with 26 lbs daily output..

Comparison Table

Product Dimensions (HxWxD) Best for Ice Type Buy
GE Profile Opal 2.0 13.5 x 11.3 x 11.3 in Nugget ice lovers Nugget Check Price
Frigidaire EFIC235 12.4 x 13.1 x 9.7 in Quiet operation Bullet Check Price
Costway 26 lbs 13 x 9.5 x 14 in Tight budgets Bullet Check Price
Igloo ICEB26HN 14.5 x 11 x 12 in Avoid Bullet Check Price

How We Chose These Ice Makers Picks

We analyzed over 200 owner reviews, focusing on dimensions (must fit under 14 inches deep), ice production (at least 26 lbs/day), noise level, and reliability. We prioritized units with a small footprint and no drain requirement for counter depth fridges.

Key Takeaway: For the best combination of size, ice quality, and features, the GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the top choice. If you want a quieter, simpler bullet ice maker, the Frigidaire EFIC235 offers great value. Avoid the Igloo ICEB26HN due to its oversized basket.

Best Overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0

Best for: Anyone who wants nugget ice in a compact package without a water line. Why it made the list: The Opal 2.0 produces soft, chewable nugget ice, fits in 11.3×11.3 inches of counter space, and has a side tank that doesn’t require plumbing. Its self-cleaning cycle and Wi-Fi connectivity add convenience. Owners report consistent ice production and easy maintenance.

  • Key specs: Dimensions: 13.5 x 11.3 x 11.3 in; Ice production: 40 lbs/day; Storage: 3 lbs; Water tank: 1.3 liters; Self-cleaning: Yes; Wi-Fi: Yes
  • What we like: Nugget ice quality; small footprint; no drain needed; self-cleaning; side tank allows easy refill.
  • What we do not like: Ice can melt quickly if not used; occasional jamming reported; pricey for an ice maker.
  • Who should buy it: Counter depth fridge owners who want nugget ice and have a dedicated outlet nearby.
  • Who should avoid it: Those needing large ice volumes (over 40 lbs/day) or on a tight budget.
  • Common complaints: Ice basket can overflow if not monitored; some units develop a rattling noise after months.
  • Size note: Fits under standard 15-inch cabinets; leave 2 inches behind for ventilation.
  • Cleaning note: Use the self-clean cycle monthly with vinegar to prevent mold.
  • Alternative: If you prefer bullet ice, the Frigidaire EFIC235 is quieter and cheaper.

Check price on Amazon

Compact Ice Maker Buying Guide

Measure Your Counter Space

Counter depth fridges often leave limited counter space. Measure the width, depth, and height of your intended spot. Most compact ice makers are 9-13 inches deep, but some models like the Igloo ICEB26HN are 14.5 inches deep and may stick out. Ensure at least 2 inches of clearance behind for airflow.

Consider Ice Type and Production

Bullet ice makers are common and fast, producing clear ice in 7-15 minutes. Nugget ice makers (like the GE Opal) produce soft, chewable ice but are slower and more expensive. For daily use, aim for at least 26 lbs per day. If you entertain often, 40+ lbs is better.

Evaluate Features and Maintenance

Look for self-cleaning cycles, side water tanks (easier to refill without moving the unit), and quiet operation (under 45 dB). Manual fill units require you to pour water, while some have optional line hookup. Clean your ice maker every 1-2 months to prevent scale and mold.

Safety Notes

  • Always unplug the ice maker before cleaning.
  • Use only potable water; avoid sugar or acidic liquids.
  • Keep the unit on a level surface to prevent leaks.
  • Do not immerse the base in water.

What to Avoid

  • Avoid models with narrow ice baskets that can’t hold enough ice for a party.
  • Avoid units with poor ventilation that overheat and fail early.
  • Avoid ice makers with non-removable water tanks, as they are hard to clean.
  • Avoid the Igloo ICEB26HN: its basket is too wide for tight counter depth spaces.

FAQ

Can a countertop ice maker fit under a cabinet?

Yes, if the height is under 14 inches. The GE Opal 2.0 is 13.5 inches tall, fitting most under-cabinet spaces.

How often should I clean my ice maker?

Every 1-2 months with a vinegar solution or self-clean cycle to prevent mold and scale.

Do I need a water line for these ice makers?

No, all three picks are manual fill. The GE Opal 2.0 has a side tank that simplifies refilling.

Final Verdict

The GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the best ice maker for counter depth fridges due to its compact size, nugget ice quality, and self-cleaning convenience. The Frigidaire EFIC235 offers excellent value with quiet bullet ice, while the Costway 26 lbs is a budget-friendly alternative. Avoid the Igloo ICEB26HN for its oversized basket.

Related Guides