Category
Ice Makers
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning,…
101+
Reviews
2026
Updated
100%
Honest
All
Top Rated
Newest
A to Z
1
8.9
Foam core insulation keeps ice solid for 8 hours.
Stainless steel interior resists odors and stains.
Tight-fitting lid with gasket prevents warm air entry.
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
3
8.9
Anodized aircraft-grade aluminum plates
Melts a 2.4 inch sphere in about 60 seconds
Gravity-drop design needs no twisting or force
4
8.6
Shielded polycarbonate scoop with integrated hand guard
Guardian caddy mounts beside the ice maker and drains drips
Meets commercial ice-handling sanitation standards
Top pick: GE Profile Opal 2.0 produces 24 lbs/day nugget ice with 3 lb storage.
Best value: hOmeLabs makes 26 lbs/day bullet ice, holds 2.5 lbs.
Budget friendly: Frigidaire EFIC108 makes 26 lbs/day bullet ice, holds 1.5 lbs.
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
8
8.7
Scotsman Prodigy C0322: self-cleaning, 330 lb/day nugget ice, Energy Star rated.
Manitowoc ID1502A: 300 lb/day cube ice, reliable compressor, good value.
Hoshizaki KM-515BAJ: 515 lb/day crescent cubes, heavy-duty, expensive.
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Ice Makers Buying Guide
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning, with honest notes on what these machines can and cannot do.