Category
Ice Makers
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning,…
101+
Reviews
2026
Updated
100%
Honest
All
Top Rated
Newest
A to Z
1
8.7
Makes 2.5-inch spheres that melt slower than cubes
Two-piece stackable molds with a marked fill line
BPA-free and dishwasher safe
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
3
8.9
Produces up to 24 lbs of ice per day, enough for parties.
Nugget ice is soft and chewable, ideal for cocktails.
Self-cleaning cycles make maintenance easy.
Frigidaire EFIC235: Best overall, 26 lbs/day, sturdy scoop, self-cleaning.
hOmeLabs Portable Ice Maker: Best value, 26 lbs/day, decent scoop, compact.
AGLISSE Countertop Ice Maker: Best budget, but flimsy scoop and inconsistent ice.
5
8.7
OEM parts guarantee fit and reliability.
Check your model number before buying.
Aftermarket units can save money but may have issues.
530 lbs daily output for the Scotsman Prodigy Elite handles peak demand
Self-cleaning cycle reduces scale and labor costs
NSF certified for commercial food safety
7
8.5
Uniform 1.25 inch square cubes
Reinforced walls prevent carry spills
Food-grade silicone, dishwasher safe
8
9.0
Chewable nugget ice, roughly 38 lb per day
Built-in cleaning cycle with app reminders
Removable side water tank
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Expert researched
Top rated pick
Editor recommended
Ice Makers Buying Guide
Nugget, bullet or clear cocktail ice, made at home on demand. We compare countertop and undercounter ice makers on ice type, daily output, noise and cleaning, with honest notes on what these machines can and cannot do.