If you want better-tasting tap water without the plastic bottle waste, both Brita and Pur make solid pitcher filters. The short answer: Brita excels at improving taste and odor for most municipal water, while Pur filters out more contaminants including lead and mercury, making it the better choice for well water or older plumbing. Your decision comes down to what’s in your water and how much you’re willing to spend on replacement filters.

Quick Answer

Brita vs Pur: both reduce common contaminants, but Pur removes more (including lead and mercury) and uses a longer-lasting filter. Brita costs less upfront and has more pitcher styles. Pur filters last 3 months vs Brita’s 2 months for standard filters. Neither removes fluoride, dissolved solids, or bacteria. For general taste improvement, Brita is fine; for heavy metals or well water, choose Pur.

  • Contaminant Reduction: Brita reduces chlorine taste, odor, zinc, and copper. Pur reduces chlorine, lead, mercury, copper, zinc, and 70+ other contaminants including certain pesticides and VOCs.
  • Filter Lifespan: Standard Brita filters last 2 months or 40 gallons. Pur filters last 3 months or 40 gallons. Brita Longlast filters last 6 months but cost more.
  • Certification: Both are NSF certified. Brita is certified under NSF 42 (taste/odor) and 53 (health contaminants). Pur is certified under NSF 42, 53, and 401 (emerging contaminants).
  • Price: Brita pitchers are generally less expensive than Pur pitchers. Replacement filters are also cheaper for Brita per filter, but Pur lasts longer so annual cost is similar.
  • Pitcher Design: Brita offers more pitcher sizes and styles (including bottle and faucet mount). Pur has fewer models but all are BPA-free and fit most fridge shelves.

What Each Filter Removes

Brita standard filters use activated carbon and ion exchange resin to reduce chlorine taste and odor, copper, cadmium, and mercury. They are certified under NSF 42 and 53 for these claims. However, they do not remove lead, arsenic, fluoride, or most pharmaceuticals. Brita’s Longlast+ filter adds coconut carbon and lasts 6 months, removing lead and asbestos as well.

Pur filters use a carbon block with a non-woven membrane that traps smaller particles. They are certified under NSF 42, 53, and 401, meaning they reduce over 70 contaminants including lead, mercury, certain pesticides, and industrial chemicals. Pur also reduces trace levels of pharmaceuticals (like ibuprofen and BPA) that Brita does not. Neither filter removes dissolved solids (TDS), fluoride, or bacteria—if you need those, consider reverse osmosis.

Filter Lifespan and Replacement Cost

Standard Brita filters need changing every 2 months or 40 gallons. A 3-pack of standard Brita filters costs about the same as a 3-pack of Pur filters, but Pur filters last 3 months (40 gallons). So over a year, Brita requires 6 changes, Pur requires 4. Brita Longlast+ filters last 6 months (120 gallons) and cost more per filter but less per gallon than standard.

Pur’s filter life is 3 months regardless of water quality; Brita’s standard filter life can be shorter if water is very hard or dirty. Both have indicator lights on some models to remind you when to change. If you forget, Pur’s filter can go longer without bypassing contaminants, while Brita’s standard filter may start releasing trapped particles after 2 months.

Pitcher Design and Fridge Fit

Brita offers the widest variety: classic pitchers in 5, 6, 8, and 10 cup sizes, plus the Stream (slim), Grand (large capacity), and the UltraMax (19 cups). Most have a flip lid for easy refilling. The Brita bottle and faucet mount are also popular. Pitchers are BPA-free but some users report the lid latch breaks after a year.

Pur has fewer options: the Classic 7-cup, the 11-cup Ultimate, and the 30-cup dispenser. The Pur pitchers are designed to fit in standard fridge shelves (9.5 inches tall). The Ultimate model has a spigot for dispensing without opening the lid. Pur’s filter is larger than Brita’s, so it takes up more space inside the pitcher. Some users find the Pur lid harder to remove for cleaning.

Installation and Setup

  1. Unbox the pitcher and wash all parts (except the filter) with warm soapy water. Rinse thoroughly.
  2. Remove the filter from its packaging. For Brita: soak the filter in cold tap water for 15 minutes, then rinse under running water for 10 seconds. For Pur: run cold water through the filter for 10 minutes to flush carbon fines.
  3. Insert the filter into the reservoir. Brita filters snap into place; Pur filters push down until seated.
  4. Fill the reservoir with cold tap water and discard the first two pitcher-fulls (Brita) or one pitcher-full (Pur) to flush any loose carbon.
  5. Your filter is ready. Always use cold water only—hot water can damage the filter media.

Setup takes about 20 minutes for Brita (soak time) and 15 minutes for Pur (flush time). Both are straightforward, but Pur’s initial flush produces more black specks (carbon fines) that can be alarming if you don’t expect them.

Performance: Taste and Flow Rate

In blind taste tests, most people cannot tell a difference between Brita and Pur filtered water. Both remove chlorine effectively, leaving a neutral taste. Brita may leave a slight “papery” taste from the filter when new; Pur has a more mineral taste initially. After a few gallons, both produce clean, crisp water.

Flow rate: Brita filters water faster because the carbon is granular. A full Brita reservoir filters in about 2-3 minutes. Pur uses a denser carbon block, so it’s slower—3-5 minutes for a full reservoir. If you refill frequently, Brita is more convenient. However, Pur’s slower flow means better contact time and potentially better contaminant removal.

Pro Tips

  • If you have hard water, buy the Brita Longlast+ filter—it handles sediment better and lasts 6 months vs 2 for standard.
  • For well water, always choose Pur because it removes more heavy metals and pesticides; Brita does not remove iron or sulfur smell.
  • To extend filter life, rinse the filter under cold water every month to remove trapped particles, especially if you see slow flow.
  • Store your pitcher in the fridge, not on the counter—cold water filters faster and carbon is more effective at lower temperatures.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Don’t use hot water in the pitcher—it can release carbon fines and damage the filter media, reducing effectiveness.
  • Don’t ignore the change indicator or calendar—expired filters can become a breeding ground for bacteria if left in water for months.
  • Don’t assume all Brita filters are the same—the standard and Longlast+ have different contaminant removal; check your water report first.
  • Don’t buy a used pitcher without replacing the filter—old filters may be saturated and can leach contaminants back into the water.

FAQ

Can Brita or Pur remove fluoride?

No, neither Brita nor Pur standard filters remove fluoride. You need a specialized filter with activated alumina or reverse osmosis to reduce fluoride. Some third-party filters fit Brita pitchers but are not certified.

Which filter is better for lead removal?

Pur is better for lead removal. Pur is certified to reduce lead by over 99%, while Brita standard filters do not remove lead. Only Brita Longlast+ removes lead, but not as effectively as Pur.

How often should I replace the pitcher itself?

Plastic pitchers generally last 2-3 years before the plastic may start to crack or absorb odors. Brita and Pur recommend replacing the entire pitcher every 1-2 years for hygiene, but many users keep them longer. Wash the pitcher weekly with mild soap.

The Bottom Line

Ultimately, the choice between Brita and Pur depends on your water quality and budget. If you just want better-tasting tap water and don’t have lead concerns, Brita is more affordable and faster. If you have older pipes, well water, or want the broadest contaminant protection, Pur is the safer bet. Both are reliable brands with millions of happy users—you can’t go wrong, just pick the one that matches your needs.

Related Guides