For most homes that want nugget ice, our top pick is the GE Profile Opal 2.0. Important to know up front: the Opal is a countertop (freestanding) nugget ice maker, not a built-in plumbed unit. It sits on the counter, recirculates its own melt water so it needs no drain line, produces nugget ice, and has a self-cleaning cycle. If you specifically need a true built-in undercounter model that plumbs into a water supply and drain, that is a separate category we cover in the buying guide below. We compared top models across key specs to help you choose.
These models range in daily output and bin capacity. Built-in undercounter units plumb into a drain line; countertop nugget makers like the Opal recirculate their melt water and need no drain. The best overall balances ice type, production speed, and reliability.
- Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0: nugget ice, 50 lbs/day, self-cleaning, WiFi
- Best value: NewAir AI-200R: bullet ice, 28 lbs/day, affordable, compact
- Best budget: Costway EP24781: bullet ice, 40 lbs/day, low cost, easy install
- Avoid: Models with plastic internal components that crack over time; check for stainless steel interiors
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.
Quick Picks
- Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0, Nugget ice, 50 lbs/day, self-cleaning, WiFi. Check price on Amazon
- Best value: NewAir AI-200R, Bullet ice, 28 lbs/day, affordable, compact.
- Best budget: Costway EP24781, Bullet ice, 40 lbs/day, low cost, easy install.
Comparison Table
| Product | Ice Type | Daily Output | Bin Capacity | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| GE Profile Opal 2.0 | Nugget | 50 lbs | 3 lbs | Check Price |
| NewAir AI-200R | Bullet | 28 lbs | 1.5 lbs | Check Price |
| Costway EP24781 | Bullet | 40 lbs | 2.5 lbs | Check Price |
| EdgeStar IB250SS | Cube | 50 lbs | 25 lbs | Check Price |
How We Chose These Undercounter Ice Maker Picks
We selected these models based on ice type preference, production capacity, bin storage, ease of installation, and owner-reported reliability. We prioritized units with stainless steel interiors and self-cleaning features.
Key Takeaway: Choose nugget ice for texture, bullet ice for speed. Ensure your cabinet has a drain line and ventilation. The GE Profile Opal 2.0 offers the best combination of ice quality and convenience.
Best Overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0
Best for: Nugget ice lovers who want a smart, self-cleaning countertop unit and do not need a built-in plumbed model. Why it made the list: The Opal 2.0 produces soft, chewable nugget ice at 50 lbs per day, has a 3 lb bin, and includes a self-cleaning cycle. It connects to WiFi for remote monitoring and fits standard 15-inch cabinet spaces.
- Key specs: Nugget ice; 50 lbs/day; 3 lb bin; 15x17x19 inches; 115V; stainless steel exterior and interior
- What we like: Self-cleaning cycle; nugget ice texture; WiFi app control; quiet operation at 52 dB
- What we do not like: Bin holds only 3 lbs; requires drain line; plastic ice chute can crack if frozen
- Who should buy it: Those who want premium nugget ice without a countertop unit
- Who should avoid it: If you need large batches of ice for parties, bin capacity may be too small
- Common complaints: Ice chute jams if ice sits too long; WiFi setup can be finicky
- Size note: Fits standard 15-inch wide cabinet cutout; requires 2-inch rear ventilation
- Cleaning note: Self-cleaning cycle uses vinegar; recommended every 6 months
- Alternative: GE Profile Opal (first gen) if you don’t need WiFi
Undercounter Ice Maker Buying Guide
Ice Type
Nugget ice is soft and chewable, great for drinks and chewing. Bullet ice is hard and clear, melts slower. Cube ice is traditional but requires larger units. Choose based on your preference.
Production and Storage
Daily output ranges from 25 to 50 lbs. Bin capacity matters: larger bins (3+ lbs) let you store more ice, but ice can melt and refreeze into a block if left too long. Most units produce 8-12 ice cubes per cycle.
Installation and Maintenance
True built-in undercounter units require a drain line (gravity or pump) and a water supply line. Countertop nugget makers like the GE Profile Opal recirculate their melt water, so they need no drain and you simply refill the reservoir. Self-cleaning cycles reduce buildup. Stainless steel interiors resist mold better than plastic.
Safety Notes
- Ensure proper ventilation around the unit to prevent overheating.
- Use a dedicated GFCI outlet near water sources.
- Do not block the drain line; check for kinks.
- Clean the unit regularly to prevent mold and bacteria growth.
What to Avoid
- Avoid models with plastic ice chutes that can crack in freezing temperatures.
- Avoid units with poor insulation that cause ice melting and refreezing.
- Avoid buying a model without a self-cleaning cycle if you plan heavy use.
- Avoid units that require a pump drain if your setup has a gravity drain available.
FAQ
Do undercounter ice makers need a drain?
It depends on the type. True built-in undercounter units require a drain line (usually gravity, sometimes a pump) to remove wastewater. Countertop nugget makers like the GE Profile Opal recirculate their melt water and need no drain, though they are not built-in units.
How much ice does an undercounter ice maker produce per day?
Typical output ranges from 25 to 50 lbs per day, depending on the model and ambient temperature.
Can I install an undercounter ice maker myself?
If you have basic plumbing and electrical skills, yes. You need a water line and drain line. Some models require a dedicated electrical circuit.
Final Verdict
The GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the best pick for most homes that want nugget ice without plumbing, thanks to its self-cleaning cycle and smart features. It is a countertop unit rather than a built-in undercounter model. The NewAir AI-200R offers great value for bullet ice lovers, and the Costway EP24781 is a solid budget pick. Avoid models with plastic internals and limited ventilation.
