The best ice maker with a cube tray for most households is the GE Profile Opal 2.0, thanks to its combination of nugget ice production, a removable cube tray for easy scooping, and a self-cleaning cycle. Whether you need a countertop nugget ice maker or a built-in unit for your kitchen island, this guide covers four top models based on real owner feedback and spec analysis.

Quick Answer

Our picks are based on ice production speed, cube quality, ease of cleaning, and storage capacity. We analyzed hundreds of Amazon reviews and prioritized models with reliable performance and minimal maintenance issues.

  • Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0: produces nugget ice, has a removable cube tray, and self-cleaning feature.
  • Best value: hOmeLabs Countertop Nugget Ice Maker: affordable nugget ice with a compact cube tray.
  • Best budget: Frigidaire EFIC117: low-cost countertop ice maker with a traditional cube tray.
  • Avoid: Aobosi Countertop Ice Maker: common complaints about slow ice production and frequent jams.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.

Quick Picks

  • Best overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0, Nugget ice with a removable tray and self-cleaning cycle.. Check price on Amazon
  • Best value: hOmeLabs Countertop Nugget Ice Maker, Nugget ice at a lower price with a decent cube tray..
  • Best budget: Frigidaire EFIC117, Simple bullet ice maker with a pull-out tray..

Comparison Table

Product Type Ice Shape Best for Tray Type Buy
GE Profile Opal 2.0 Nugget Nugget lovers who want a tray Removable cube tray Check Price
hOmeLabs Countertop Nugget Ice Maker Nugget Budget-conscious nugget fans Removable cube tray Check Price
Frigidaire EFIC117 Bullet Basic ice needs on a budget Pull-out cube tray Check Price
Aobosi Countertop Ice Maker Bullet Avoid due to jamming issues Removable tray with jamming Check Price

How We Chose These Ice Makers Picks

We focused on models that include a dedicated cube tray (not just a basket) and produce clear, consistent ice. We prioritized nugget ice makers for their chewable texture and looked at production rates, storage capacity, and cleaning ease. We excluded units with widespread reports of jamming or slow ice production.

Key Takeaway: If you want chewable nugget ice with a convenient cube tray, the GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the clear winner. For a similar experience on a budget, the hOmeLabs model is a solid second choice. The Frigidaire EFIC117 works for basic bullet ice at a low price, but avoid the Aobosi due to reliability concerns.

Best Overall: GE Profile Opal 2.0

GE Profile Opal 2.0

Best for: Nugget ice enthusiasts who want a countertop ice maker with a removable cube tray and self-cleaning. Why it made the list: The GE Profile Opal 2.0 stands out because it produces soft, chewable nugget ice, includes a removable cube tray that fits standard ice buckets, and has a built-in self-cleaning cycle that reduces mold buildup. It also connects to the SmartHQ app for scheduling and maintenance reminders.

  • Key specs: Ice shape: Nugget. Production: up to 24 lbs per day. Storage: 3 lbs. Tray: removable cube tray. Self-cleaning: yes. Dimensions: 17.3 x 10.6 x 14.2 inches.
  • What we like: Chewable nugget ice; removable cube tray fits standard ice buckets; self-cleaning cycle reduces manual effort; Wi-Fi enabled for scheduling.
  • What we do not like: Large footprint; water reservoir can develop slime if not cleaned regularly; ice melt rate is faster than traditional ice; price is high.
  • Who should buy it: Households that love nugget ice for drinks or smoothies; those who want a tray for easy transport to parties.
  • Who should avoid it: People short on counter space; those who prefer traditional clear cubes; budget shoppers.
  • Common complaints: Condensation on the unit; ice melts quickly in the bin; plastic parts feel slightly cheap for the price.
  • Size note: Requires about 6 inches of clearance above to open the lid. Not suitable for under-cabinet installation.
  • Cleaning note: Self-cleaning cycle uses vinegar or cleaner; still need to wipe down the interior and drain the reservoir weekly.
  • Alternative: hOmeLabs Countertop Nugget Ice Maker: same ice shape, lower price, but no Wi-Fi or self-cleaning.

Check price on Amazon

Countertop Ice Maker with Cube Tray Buying Guide

Ice Shape and Texture

The most common ice shapes are bullet (clear, hard) and nugget (soft, chewable). Bullet ice is produced by most budget models and melts slower, while nugget ice is preferred for sodas and cocktails but melts faster. If you want a cube tray, ensure the model includes a removable tray rather than a fixed basket, as trays allow for easier scooping and transfer to coolers.

Production Rate and Storage

Countertop ice makers typically produce 20-40 lbs of ice per day. For a household of 2-4 people, 24 lbs/day is sufficient. Storage capacity matters: a 3 lb bin fills quickly but is fine for immediate use. Larger storage bins (up to 5 lbs) reduce how often you need to empty the tray. Note that ice makers do not freeze the ice solid; it melts faster than freezer ice, so plan to use it within a few hours.

Cleaning and Maintenance

All countertop ice makers require regular cleaning to prevent mold and slime. Models with a self-cleaning cycle simplify this, but you still need to drain and wipe the interior weekly. Removable trays and baskets are easier to wash. Avoid models with non-removable components that trap water. Also check if the water pump is accessible for descaling, as mineral buildup can reduce performance.

Safety Notes

  • Place the ice maker on a level, dry surface away from heat sources.
  • Do not immerse the unit in water; only wipe exterior with a damp cloth.
  • Unplug before cleaning or servicing.
  • Use only clean, potable water to avoid contamination.

What to Avoid

  • Avoid models with non-removable ice trays; they are harder to clean.
  • Avoid models with frequent jamming complaints; check recent reviews.
  • Avoid very cheap units that use a single ice size setting; they often produce inconsistent cubes.
  • Avoid units with poor insulation that cause rapid ice melting.

FAQ

Can I use an ice maker with a cube tray to make large cocktail cubes?

Most countertop ice makers produce small bullet or nugget ice, not large cocktail cubes. If you need large clear cubes, consider a separate ice cube tray in your freezer or a dedicated clear ice maker.

How often should I clean my countertop ice maker?

At least once a week, more often if you use it daily. Use a vinegar solution or a recommended cleaner to prevent mold and scale buildup.

Do ice makers with cube trays keep the ice frozen?

No, countertop ice makers are not freezers. The ice will melt over time (typically within a few hours) unless transferred to a freezer. Use the ice promptly or store in a freezer bag.

Final Verdict

The GE Profile Opal 2.0 is the best ice maker with a cube tray for most people, offering nugget ice and a removable tray with hOmeLabs as a value alternative. For basic bullet ice, the Frigidaire EFIC117 works on a budget, but avoid the Aobosi due to jamming issues.

Related Guides