The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the best toaster oven for pizza because it fits a 13-inch pie, hits its 450-degree ceiling quickly, and its element control browns cheese on top while crisping the crust underneath. Most toaster ovens fail at pizza for one of two reasons: the rack is too small for a standard frozen pizza, or the heat is too weak and uneven for a crisp bottom. Every pick here clears the size bar, and one of them, the Pizzaiolo, goes far beyond it. Here is how they stack up.
The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the best toaster oven for pizza, fitting 13-inch pies with even top-and-bottom browning. If pizza is your main event rather than a side use, the Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo reaches genuine pizzeria temperatures.
- Best overall: Breville Smart Oven Pro, fits a 13-inch pizza with smart element control for even browning
- Best value: Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fry Oven SP101, a flat, fast oven that handles 13-inch pizzas
- Best budget: BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Toaster Oven, fits a 12-inch pizza for very little money
- Avoid: Compact 4-slice toaster ovens; most max out around a 9-inch pizza and cook it unevenly
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.
Quick Picks
- Best overall: Breville Smart Oven Pro, Fits a 13-inch pizza and its element control delivers browned cheese over a crisp bottom.. Check price on Amazon
- Best value: Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fry Oven SP101, Fast-heating flat oven that crisps a 13-inch pizza and flips up to store against the backsplash..
- Best budget: BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Toaster Oven, A wide-body basic that fits 12-inch pizzas for a fraction of the price of the others..
Comparison Table
| Oven | Max pizza size | Best for | Top temperature | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breville Smart Oven Pro | 13 inches | All-around pizza and daily use | 450 F | Check Price |
| Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fry Oven SP101 | 13 inches | Fast weeknight frozen pizza | 450 F | Check Price |
| BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Toaster Oven | 12 inches | Budget buyers and dorms | 450 F | Check Price |
| Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo | 12 inches | Serious homemade pizza | 750 F | Check Price |
How We Chose These Toasters Picks
We compared rack dimensions against real pizza sizes, checked maximum temperatures and element layouts, and read owner feedback focused specifically on crust results and frozen pizza fit. Ovens that could not fit at least a 12-inch pizza were cut regardless of how well they toast.
Key Takeaway: For pizza, buy on two numbers first: the largest pizza the rack actually fits and the highest temperature the oven actually reaches. Everything else is secondary.
Best Overall: Breville Smart Oven Pro
Best for: Anyone who wants one countertop oven that does excellent pizza and everything else, from roasting vegetables to toast. Why it made the list: Its element control adjusts power between the top and bottom heating elements through the cook, which is exactly what pizza needs: strong bottom heat early for the crust, then top heat to finish the cheese. Add a cavity that genuinely fits a 13-inch pizza and a convection fan, and it beats full-size ovens for weeknight pies.
- Key specs: 1800 watts, element control with 10 cooking functions including a dedicated pizza setting, convection fan, interior that fits a 13-inch pizza, temperature range up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, interior light.
- What we like: Even top and bottom browning, quick preheat compared with a full-size oven, and a pizza function that gets frozen pies right without babysitting.
- What we do not like: It is large on the counter, the exterior gets hot enough to demand clearance, and at 450 degrees it still cannot produce true pizzeria char on homemade dough.
- Who should buy it: Households that make pizza weekly, frozen or homemade, and want a versatile everyday countertop oven rather than a single-purpose machine.
- Who should avoid it: Anyone chasing genuine Neapolitan-style leopard-spotted crust; that requires the 750-degree Pizzaiolo or an outdoor pizza oven, not a conventional toaster oven.
- Common complaints: Counter footprint, heat radiating from the top panel, and the non-stick interior coating showing wear after years of high-heat pizza use.
- Size note: Measure your counter and the clearance under your cabinets before buying; you need open space above and behind the oven for venting.
- Cleaning note: Pull the crumb tray after cheese-drip sessions and wipe the interior once it cools; baked-on cheese smokes on the next preheat.
- Alternative: The Breville Smart Oven Pizzaiolo if homemade pizza is the main reason you are shopping.
Toaster Buying Guide for Pizza Lovers
Heat is everything for crust
Great pizza wants strong, fast bottom heat. Most toaster ovens top out at 450 degrees, which is fine for frozen pizza and respectable for homemade if you preheat a pan or small pizza steel inside for 15 minutes first. The Pizzaiolo is the exception, reaching around 750 degrees for genuine pizzeria-style char in a couple of minutes.
Measure the rack, not the box
Marketing photos hide how small some interiors are. A standard large frozen pizza is 12 inches and many premium frozen pies are close to 13, so check the stated pizza capacity and the actual rack width. A pizza that touches the walls will burn at the edge and steam in the middle.
Convection and element placement
A convection fan evens out hot spots and helps the top finish at the same time as the base. Ovens with element control, like the Breville, shift power to the bottom early and the top late, mimicking a deck oven. On basic models, put the rack in the lower position and rotate the pizza halfway to compensate.
Safety Notes
- Toaster oven exteriors get hot at pizza temperatures; keep several inches of clearance from walls, cabinets, and anything plastic.
- Empty the crumb tray regularly; built-up crumbs and dripped cheese are the most common cause of smoke and small fires.
- Use parchment only within its rated temperature, and never let it hang near the elements.
- Use oven mitts and pull the rack out to retrieve pizza; the shallow cavity puts your forearm close to the top element.
What to Avoid
- Compact 2-slice and 4-slice toaster ovens; most cannot fit anything larger than a 9-inch pizza.
- Ovens that hide their maximum temperature in the fine print; some budget models stop at 400 degrees, which makes pale, soft crust.
- Putting a cold pizza stone into a preheated oven, since thermal shock can crack it; preheat the stone with the oven instead.
- Cooking pizza on the top rack position, where cheese burns before the base crisps.
FAQ
Can you cook a frozen pizza in a toaster oven?
Yes, and often better than in a full-size oven because the small cavity preheats fast and holds heat close to the pie. Check the box diameter against your oven first, use the middle or lower rack, and use convection if you have it.
Should you use a pizza stone or steel in a toaster oven?
A small steel or stone helps crisp homemade crust, and steel works better at toaster oven temperatures. Make sure it fits with clearance on all sides, preheat it with the oven for at least 15 minutes, and mind the weight on lightweight racks.
Why does pizza come out soggy in the middle?
Usually the oven was not fully preheated, the pizza sat on a cold pan, or the rack was too high. Preheat thoroughly, use the lower rack position for stronger bottom heat, and slide the pie directly onto the rack or a preheated surface instead of a room-temperature tray.
Final Verdict
The Breville Smart Oven Pro is the best toaster oven for pizza thanks to its 13-inch capacity and element control, with the Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fry Oven SP101 a faster, cheaper option for weeknight frozen pies and the BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Toaster Oven covering budget buyers who still want a full 12-inch fit.
