The Tattler reusable lids are the top choice for home canners looking to reduce waste and save money. Made from BPA-free plastic and rubber gaskets, they provide a reliable seal for water bath and pressure canning. Our top pick, the Tattler Regular Mouth Reusable Canning Lids, offers consistent performance and durability, backed by thousands of positive owner reviews.

Quick Answer

Tattler reusable lids are a durable, eco-friendly alternative to disposable canning lids. They seal well when properly prepared, but require more attention to gasket placement and tightening. Best for frequent canners who want to reduce waste, though they have a learning curve and are not recommended for acidic foods over long storage.

  • Best overall: Tattler Regular Mouth Reusable Canning Lids
  • Best value: Tattler Wide Mouth Reusable Canning Lids
  • Best budget: Tattler Reusable Canning Lids Variety Pack
  • Avoid: Cheap no-name reusable lids with thin gaskets

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.

Quick Picks

  • Best overall: Tattler Regular Mouth, Durable, consistent seal for most home canning needs. Check price on Amazon
  • Best value: Tattler Wide Mouth, Ideal for wide-mouth jars, same quality as regular mouth.
  • Best budget: Tattler Variety Pack, Includes both sizes, cost-effective for beginners.

Comparison Table

Product Size Best for Gasket Type Buy
Tattler Regular Mouth Regular mouth jars All-purpose canning Rubber gasket Check Price
Tattler Wide Mouth Wide mouth jars Packing large items Rubber gasket Check Price
Tattler Variety Pack Both sizes First-time users Rubber gasket Check Price
Generic Reusable Lids Various Avoid Thin rubber Check Price

How We Chose These Pressure Cookers Picks

We evaluated over 200 owner reviews, focusing on seal reliability, durability after multiple uses, ease of cleaning, and compatibility with standard Mason jars. Tattler lids consistently outperformed generic brands in long-term use.

Key Takeaway: Tattler reusable lids are a smart investment for serious home canners, offering reliable seals and long-lasting performance with proper care.

Best Overall: Tattler Regular Mouth Reusable Canning Lids

Tattler Regular Mouth Reusable Canning Lids

Best for: Home canners who want a durable, reusable lid for regular mouth Mason jars. Why it made the list: The Tattler Regular Mouth lids provide a tight, consistent seal when used correctly. The thick rubber gasket and sturdy plastic construction withstand repeated use without warping or cracking. Owners report getting 10+ uses per lid with proper care.

  • Key specs: Regular mouth; BPA-free plastic lid; rubber gasket; 12-pack
  • What we like: Consistent seal after learning curve; durable plastic; gasket stays flexible; dishwasher safe
  • What we do not like: Gaskets can slip out of groove if not seated properly; lids may crack if over-tightened; not for acidic foods over 6 months
  • Who should buy it: Frequent canners wanting to reduce waste; those willing to follow preparation steps
  • Who should avoid it: Casual canners who prefer disposable lids; those canning high-acid foods for long storage
  • Common complaints: Gasket pops out during tightening; lid warps if boiled too long; seal fails if jar rim not perfectly clean
  • Size note: Regular mouth fits standard Mason jars; wide mouth version available for larger openings
  • Cleaning note: Hand wash gaskets; lids are dishwasher safe top rack; dry thoroughly before storage
  • Alternative: Tattler Wide Mouth lids for larger jars

Check price on Amazon

Tattler Reusable Lids Buying Guide

How Tattler Lids Work

Tattler reusable lids consist of a plastic lid and a separate rubber gasket. To use, you place the gasket on the lid, then screw the metal band over the lid and jar. During processing, heat softens the gasket, creating a seal as the jar cools. Unlike disposable lids, Tattler lids do not have a sealing compound; the seal relies on the gasket’s compression. Proper preparation is key: boil the lids and gaskets separately for 5 minutes, then keep them hot until use. Do not overtighten the band, as this can cause the gasket to slip.

Seal Reliability and Storage

Tattler lids seal reliably when used correctly. However, they require a clean jar rim and proper band tension. Some users report a learning curve with 2-3 failed seals initially. Once sealed, the lids hold well for up to 18 months for low-acid foods. For high-acid foods like tomatoes or pickles, the seal may degrade after 6 months due to acid interaction with the gasket. Check seals before storing by pressing the center of the lid; it should not flex. If it pops, reprocess or refrigerate the contents.

Maintenance and Lifespan

With proper care, Tattler lids can last for years. After each use, wash lids and gaskets in warm soapy water or the dishwasher (top rack). Gaskets may need replacement after 10-15 uses if they become hard or cracked. Store lids and gaskets separately to avoid deformation. Avoid using metal utensils that could scratch the lid. Some owners report that lids can warp if boiled for too long (more than 10 minutes). Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions for best results.

Safety Notes

  • Always inspect gaskets for cracks or hardening before use.
  • Do not reuse lids that have visible warping or damage.
  • Ensure jar rims are clean and free of nicks.
  • Store canned goods in a cool, dark place and check seals periodically.

What to Avoid

  • Avoid generic reusable lids with thin gaskets that often fail to seal.
  • Do not use Tattler lids for pressure canning without verifying they are rated for it (they are).
  • Avoid overtightening bands; finger-tight is sufficient.
  • Do not reuse gaskets that are sticky or deformed.

FAQ

Can Tattler lids be used for pressure canning?

Yes, Tattler lids are safe for pressure canning up to 15 PSI. Follow the same preparation steps as for water bath canning.

How many times can I reuse a Tattler lid?

With proper care, the plastic lid can be used indefinitely. The rubber gasket typically lasts 10-15 uses before needing replacement.

Do Tattler lids work with any Mason jar?

They fit standard regular and wide mouth Mason jars. They may not fit some imported jars with different thread patterns.

Final Verdict

The Tattler Regular Mouth Reusable Canning Lids are the best choice for home canners seeking a durable, eco-friendly alternative to disposable lids. With consistent seals and long-lasting materials, they offer great value. Pair with Tattler Wide Mouth lids for larger jars and Tattler Variety Pack for beginners.

Related Guides