The Dash Mini Pie Maker is the best pie maker machine because it turns store-bought or homemade dough into a crisp, sealed hand pie in about ten minutes, heats evenly on both plates, and takes up less counter space than a toaster. Pie makers are simple appliances, so the ranking comes down to even browning, seal quality around the crust edge, and how easy the nonstick plates are to wipe clean, and the Dash leads on all three.
The Dash Mini Pie Maker is the best pie maker machine, delivering evenly browned, well-sealed hand pies with minimal cleanup. The Breville Personal Pie Maker is the upgrade pick for deeper, diner-style pot pies if you can find it in stock.
- Best overall: Dash Mini Pie Maker
- Best value: Babycakes Mini Pie Maker
- Best budget: Brentwood Mini Pie Maker
- Avoid: Generic no-name pie makers with thin plates, they brown one side and leave the other pale
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.
Quick Picks
- Best overall: Dash Mini Pie Maker, Even browning, a tight crust seal, and a footprint small enough for any kitchen. Check price on Amazon
- Best value: Babycakes Mini Pie Maker, Bakes multiple small pies at once, good for families and batch snacks.
- Best budget: Brentwood Mini Pie Maker, Basic single-pie unit that gets the job done for occasional use.
Comparison Table
| Pie maker | Pies per batch | Best for | Crust cutter included | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dash Mini Pie Maker | 1 | Singles and small kitchens | Yes | Check Price |
| Babycakes Mini Pie Maker | 4 | Families and batch baking | Yes | Check Price |
| Brentwood Mini Pie Maker | 1 | Occasional use on a budget | No | Check Price |
| Breville Personal Pie Maker | 4 | Deep-dish personal pot pies | Yes | Check Price |
How We Chose These Small Kitchen Appliances Picks
We compared plate depth, browning evenness, edge-sealing design, and included accessories across the widely available pie maker lines, then weighed owner feedback on sticking, hot spots, and long-term nonstick durability. Machines that seal the crust rim firmly ranked highest because leaking filling is the most common pie maker frustration.
Key Takeaway: Pie makers reward simple habits: chill your dough, do not overfill past two-thirds, and brush the top crust lightly with egg or milk. Follow those three rules and even a budget unit turns out bakery-looking hand pies.
Best Overall: Dash Mini Pie Maker
Best for: Anyone who wants fast personal pies, sweet or savory, without heating a full oven, especially singles, students, and small households. Why it made the list: Both plates heat evenly so the top crust browns as well as the bottom, the clamshell presses a reliable seal into the crust edge so filling stays inside, and the whole unit wipes clean in under a minute.
- Key specs: Single-pie clamshell design, dual nonstick heating plates, indicator light, included dough cutter for tops and bottoms, compact upright-storable body
- What we like: Even browning top and bottom, a firm edge seal that stops leaks, roughly ten-minute bake times, and effortless wipe-down cleanup
- What we do not like: It only bakes one pie at a time, the shallow cavity limits how much filling fits, and there is no temperature control at all
- Who should buy it: People cooking for one or two who want quick hand pies, breakfast pies, or leftover-filled pastries without an oven
- Who should avoid it: Families feeding four or more, a multi-cavity model like the Babycakes bakes a full round in one go
- Common complaints: Owners note the fixed temperature can overbrown delicate doughs, and that overfilled pies leak and bake onto the hinge area
- Size note: The pie cavity suits roughly 4 inch rounds of dough, close to one refrigerated pie crust cut into quarters
- Cleaning note: Unplug and cool, then wipe plates with a damp cloth, never use metal utensils or abrasive pads on the nonstick surface
- Alternative: The Breville Personal Pie Maker if you want deeper pot-pie-style pies and sturdier build quality
Small Appliance Buying Guide
Capacity is the first decision
Single-cavity units are compact and cheap but feed one person at a time, while four-cavity machines turn out a family round of pies per cycle. Think about your realistic use: a weekend treat for one, or after-school snacks for three kids. Batch bakers should also check cavity depth, shallow cavities hold less filling than they appear to.
Fixed temperature means dough choice matters
Nearly all pie makers run at one preset temperature, so results depend on the dough you feed them. Standard pie crust and puff pastry brown nicely in 8 to 12 minutes, while sweet doughs with high sugar can darken fast. Since you cannot turn the heat down, check pies early on the first run of any new recipe.
Look for a real edge seal and a dough cutter
The clamshell should press a crimp into the rim so filling cannot escape, machines with flat, loose-closing lids produce open-topped messes. An included dough cutter sized to the cavities saves genuine annoyance, since guessing circle sizes with a glass leads to gaps and shrunken tops.
Safety Notes
- The exterior and especially the hinge area get hot enough to burn, handle only the cool-touch handle during baking
- Escaping steam when opening the lid is the most common pie maker injury, open it away from your face and hands
- Fruit fillings exit molten, let pies rest two to three minutes before biting
- Never wrap the cord around a still-warm unit or store it before the plates fully cool
What to Avoid
- No-name imports with thin stamped plates, they brown unevenly and the nonstick fails within months
- Units without a latch or firm-closing lid, loose lids bake open, leaky pies
- Models whose plates cannot be wiped flat, deep crevices around the seal trap burnt filling
- Anything marketed without an indicator light, guessing preheat status wastes the first pie
FAQ
Can I use store-bought pie crust in a pie maker?
Yes, refrigerated roll-out pie crust is the easiest option and one standard crust yields about four mini pie bottoms and tops. Puff pastry and biscuit dough also work well. Keep dough cold until it goes in, warm dough stretches thin and tears at the seal.
What can I make besides dessert pies?
Savory hand pies are where these machines shine: pot pie filling, taco meat and cheese, curry, breakfast egg and sausage, even leftover stew thickened slightly. Just avoid very wet fillings, anything soupy will breach the seal and burn onto the plates.
How long does a pie take in a pie maker?
Most pies finish in 8 to 12 minutes after a short preheat, roughly a third of standard oven time. Darker, sugar-heavy fillings run to the quick end. Check at 8 minutes the first time you try a new dough and filling combination.
Final Verdict
The Dash Mini Pie Maker is the best pie maker machine for fast, evenly browned hand pies, with the Babycakes Mini Pie Maker as the value pick for batch baking and the Breville Personal Pie Maker as the upgrade for deep-dish personal pot pies.
