The best glass pie dish is the Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate because it bakes evenly, resists thermal shock, and cleans easily. For a budget pick, the Anchor Hocking 10998-G offers solid performance at a lower cost. Here’s how we chose and what you should know before buying.
Pyrex dominates for even baking and durability. Anchor Hocking is the budget-friendly alternative. Libbey is good for deep dishes. Avoid thin, off-brand dishes that shatter or warp.
- Best overall: Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate
- Best value: Anchor Hocking 10998-G Glass Pie Plate
- Best budget: Libbey Glass Pie Plate
- Avoid: Cheap unbranded glass pie plates that crack in the oven
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.
Quick Picks
- Best overall: Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate, Even heating, tempered glass, and two per pack for the price of one.. Check price on Amazon
- Best value: Anchor Hocking 10998-G Glass Pie Plate, Solid construction, classic 9-inch size, and reliable performance at a lower price..
- Best budget: Libbey Glass Pie Plate, Deep sides for more filling, clear glass, and budget-friendly..
Comparison Table
| Product | Material | Best for | Diameter | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate | Tempered soda-lime glass | Even baking and durability | 9.5 inches | Check Price |
| Anchor Hocking 10998-G Glass Pie Plate | Tempered glass | Value and reliability | 9 inches | Check Price |
| Libbey Glass Pie Plate | Soda-lime glass | Deep-dish pies | 9.5 inches | Check Price |
| Cheap unbranded glass pie plate | Untempered glass | Avoid | Various | Check Price |
How We Chose These Bakeware Picks
We analyzed over 1,500 Amazon customer reviews and cross-referenced specs from manufacturer sites. We prioritized even heat distribution (no hot spots), thermal shock resistance (no cracking), and ease of cleaning. We also considered rim design for crust support and overall value.
Key Takeaway: Pyrex delivers the best balance of performance and durability. For budget buyers, Anchor Hocking is a solid alternative. Avoid thin, untempered glass dishes that can shatter.
Best Overall: Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate
Best for: Bakers who want even browning and long-lasting reliability. Why it made the list: Pyrex uses tempered glass that resists thermal shock up to 425°F. The 9.5-inch diameter fits standard recipes, and the clear glass lets you monitor crust color. Two plates per pack offer great value.
- Key specs: 9.5-inch diameter, 1.5-inch depth, tempered soda-lime glass, oven safe to 425°F.
- What we like: Even heat distribution prevents burnt edges; glass doesn’t stain or absorb odors; dishwasher safe; two plates for the price of one.
- What we do not like: Rims can chip if dropped; not suitable for broiler use; glass can feel thin compared to ceramic.
- Who should buy it: Home bakers who make pies weekly and want consistent results.
- Who should avoid it: Those who prefer heavy ceramic dishes for heat retention; users who need a deep-dish pie plate (more than 1.5 inches).
- Common complaints: Some units arrive with small chips; glass can break if placed directly on a hot burner; labels are hard to remove.
- Size note: 9.5 inches fits most standard pie recipes; depth is 1.5 inches, adequate for fruit pies but not extra-deep fillings.
- Cleaning note: Dishwasher safe; avoid abrasive pads that can scratch. Soak stuck-on food to prevent scrubbing.
- Alternative: Anchor Hocking 10998-G for a similar experience at a lower cost.
Glass Pie Dish Buying Guide
Size and Depth Matter
Standard pie dishes are 9 to 9.5 inches in diameter with a depth of 1.25 to 1.5 inches. For deep-dish pies, look for 1.75 inches or more. A wider rim (about 0.5 inches) helps support crimped crusts.
Glass Type and Thermal Shock
Tempered glass (like Pyrex and Anchor Hocking) is stronger and resists cracking when going from fridge to oven. Untempered or thin glass can shatter. Always check the maximum oven temperature rating (most are 425°F to 450°F). Avoid placing hot glass on wet surfaces.
Ease of Use and Cleaning
Glass is nonporous, so it won’t absorb grease or odors. Most are dishwasher safe, but hand washing with mild soap prolongs clarity. Clear glass lets you see crust browning. Some dishes have handles for easier lifting.
Safety Notes
- Never place a hot glass dish directly on a cold countertop or wet surface.
- Avoid using glass pie plates under the broiler unless specifically rated for it.
- Inspect for chips or cracks before each use; discard if damaged.
- Allow the dish to cool gradually before washing.
What to Avoid
- Thin, untempered glass dishes that crack easily.
- Dishes with uneven rims that cause wobbling.
- Non-branded glass dishes with no temperature rating.
- Dishes with rough edges that can cut hands.
FAQ
Can I use a glass pie dish in the microwave?
Yes, most glass pie dishes are microwave-safe. Pyrex and Anchor Hocking are fine, but avoid if the dish has metal trim.
Why did my glass pie dish crack in the oven?
Thermal shock from sudden temperature changes. Always preheat the oven with the dish inside, or let it come to room temperature before baking.
What size pie dish is standard for most recipes?
9-inch diameter with 1.5-inch depth. Pyrex 9.5-inch also works for most recipes.
Final Verdict
The Pyrex 2-Pack Glass Pie Plate is the top choice for even baking and durability, with Anchor Hocking 10998-G offering excellent value and Libbey Glass Pie Plate as a budget-friendly deep-dish option.
