The best ice cube tray for most people is the OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray because its tight lid and silicone base make filling, stacking, and releasing cubes effortless without leaks. From stackable silicone trays to jumbo cube makers, we compared four top-rated models to find the right fit for your freezer and cocktail needs.

Quick Answer

OXO Good Grips leads with no-spill design and easy release. The W&P Porter is best for compact storage and large cubes. The Tovolo Jumbo is ideal for big drinks. The classic Rubbermaid is a budget option but prone to cracking.

  • Best overall: OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
  • Best value: W&P Porter Silicone Ice Cube Tray
  • Best budget: Rubbermaid Classic Ice Cube Tray
  • Avoid: Thin, brittle plastic trays with no lid – they crack and absorb odors.

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.

Quick Picks

  • Best overall: OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray, Tight lid and flexible silicone for leak-free stacking and easy release.. Check price on Amazon
  • Best value: W&P Porter Silicone Ice Cube Tray, Compact, stackable, and produces clear, large cubes..
  • Best budget: Rubbermaid Classic Ice Cube Tray, Inexpensive and simple, but less durable..

Comparison Table

Product Material & Capacity Best for Key Feature Buy
OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray Silicone, 2 trays, 18 cubes each No-spill filling and stacking Snap-tight lid with silicone base Check Price
W&P Porter Silicone Ice Cube Tray Silicone, 1 tray, 15 large cubes Space-saving and large cubes Compact design with lid and silicone Check Price
Tovolo Jumbo Ice Cube Tray Silicone, 2 trays, 2 jumbo cubes each Cocktail enthusiasts who want slow-melt cubes Large 2.25-inch cubes with silicone lid Check Price
Rubbermaid Classic Ice Cube Tray Plastic, 2 trays, 14 cubes each Budget-friendly basic cubes Traditional twist-release design Check Price

How We Chose These Kitchen Gadgets Picks

We analyzed customer reviews, material quality, lid seal reliability, cube release ease, and stackability. We prioritized trays with silicone construction, no-spill lids, and good user ratings. We excluded trays with brittle plastic or poor seals.

Key Takeaway: For most kitchens, a silicone tray with a tight lid like the OXO Good Grips offers the best balance of convenience, durability, and space-saving stackability.

Best Overall: OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray

Best for: Anyone who wants mess-free, stackable, and easy-release ice cubes every time. Why it made the list: The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray stands out for its thoughtful design: a snap-tight lid prevents spills when carrying, and the flexible silicone base lets you pop out cubes with a simple twist. The trays stack securely, saving freezer space. Owners consistently praise the leak-proof seal and the fact that cubes don’t stick. It’s a small upgrade that solves the frustration of broken plastic trays and watery messes.

  • Key specs: Silicone with PP lid; each tray makes 18 standard cubes; 2 trays per pack; BPA-free; top-rack dishwasher safe.
  • What we like: No-spill lid seals tightly; silicone base releases cubes easily; trays stack without sliding; durable construction; dishwasher safe.
  • What we do not like: Lid can be tricky to snap on if not aligned perfectly; cubes are standard size, not large; silicone may retain odors if not cleaned promptly.
  • Who should buy it: Home cooks, families, and anyone tired of messy, hard-to-release ice trays.
  • Who should avoid it: Those who want extra-large or jumbo cubes for cocktails.
  • Common complaints: A few users report the lid warps slightly after many dishwasher cycles; some find the silicone smell lingers initially.
  • Size note: Each tray measures 10.5 x 5.5 x 2.5 inches; two trays fit side by side in most freezer doors.
  • Cleaning note: Wash before first use; top-rack dishwasher safe; avoid harsh abrasive cleaners to prevent silicone degradation.
  • Alternative: If you need larger cubes, consider the W&P Porter or Tovolo Jumbo.

Check price on Amazon

Ice Cube Tray Buying Guide

Material Matters: Silicone vs. Plastic

Silicone trays are flexible, non-stick, and durable, but can absorb odors if not cleaned. Plastic trays are cheaper but often brittle and prone to cracking in the freezer. Silicone is generally the better choice for longevity and ease of use.

Lid Design and Leak Prevention

A tight-fitting lid is crucial for preventing spills and keeping cubes fresh. Look for snap-on or slide-lock lids. Avoid trays with loose or no lids – they allow freezer burn and odor absorption.

Cube Size and Shape

Standard cubes melt quickly; large or jumbo cubes dilute drinks slower. Consider your typical use: cocktail enthusiasts may prefer jumbo, while everyday use benefits from standard or medium cubes.

Safety Notes

  • Always check that the tray is BPA-free and made from food-grade silicone or plastic.
  • Wash new trays thoroughly before first use to remove manufacturing residues.
  • Avoid overfilling – leave a small gap for expansion to prevent cracking.
  • Do not use sharp objects to remove stuck cubes; twist or flex the tray instead.

What to Avoid

  • Avoid thin, brittle plastic trays that crack in the freezer.
  • Avoid trays without lids – they expose ice to freezer odors and frost.
  • Avoid trays with complex shapes that are hard to clean or release cubes.
  • Avoid trays with loose-fitting lids that leak water when moved.

FAQ

How do I get clear ice cubes?

Use distilled water and boil it twice before freezing. Insulated trays that freeze slowly also help clarity.

Can I put silicone ice trays in the dishwasher?

Most are top-rack dishwasher safe, but check the manufacturer’s instructions. Hand washing prolongs life.

Why do my ice cubes taste like freezer?

The tray may be absorbing odors. Wash with baking soda solution, or use a tray with a tight lid to prevent odor transfer.

Final Verdict

The OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray is the top choice for its leak-proof lid, easy release, and stackable design. For larger cubes, the W&P Porter offers great value, while the Tovolo Jumbo is perfect for cocktails. The Rubbermaid Classic works on a tight budget but lacks durability.

Related Guides