The Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy is the best cleaning supplies organizer caddy because its thick molded plastic, oversized handle, and high walls carry a full load of spray bottles without flexing, tipping, or cracking, faults that kill cheaper caddies within a year. A good caddy turns cleaning from a gather-everything scavenger hunt into grabbing one handle. These four organize under-sink chaos at different sizes and budgets.
The Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy is the most durable and practical way to store and carry cleaning supplies, with a handle and wall height that keep tall spray bottles upright in transit. For divided small-item organization, the mDesign caddy adds compartments the Rubbermaid lacks.
- Best overall: Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy, thick plastic and a real handle that hauls a full load
- Best value: mDesign Divided Cleaning Caddy, compartments keep brushes and cloths sorted
- Best budget: Sterilite Divided Caddy, basic but functional under-sink organization
- Avoid: Fabric and wire caddies for liquid supplies, leaks soak fabric and bottles tip through wire gaps
Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.
Quick Picks
- Best overall: Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy, Heavy-duty molded caddy that carries a full cleaning load safely. Check price on Amazon
- Best value: mDesign Divided Cleaning Caddy, Divided sections keep sprays, brushes, and cloths in order.
- Best budget: Sterilite Divided Caddy, Simple, cheap-to-replace organization for under the sink.
Comparison Table
| Caddy | Material | Best for | Layout | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy | Thick molded plastic | Carrying supplies room to room | Open bin with center handle | Check Price |
| mDesign Divided Cleaning Caddy | Rigid BPA-free plastic | Sorted storage of mixed supplies | Divided compartments, handle | Check Price |
| Sterilite Divided Caddy | Light molded plastic | Budget under-sink organization | Divided sections, handle | Check Price |
| SimpleHouseware Cleaning Caddy | Molded plastic | Spare caddy for bathroom kits | Open sections with handle | Check Price |
How We Chose These Kitchen Storage Picks
We compared wall thickness, handle strength, compartment layout, and washability across widely sold cleaning caddies, then weighed owner feedback about cracking, tipping bottles, and chemical staining over months of use. Caddies with recurring broken-handle reports were removed from consideration.
Key Takeaway: Buy the caddy for the loaded weight, not the empty look. A full set of spray bottles is heavy, and handle strength plus wall height decide whether the caddy carries it or dumps it.
Best Overall: Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy
Best for: Anyone who carries cleaning supplies between rooms or floors and wants a caddy that will not crack or tip its load. Why it made the list: The Deluxe Carry Caddy is molded from genuinely thick plastic with a wide, comfortable center handle that does not flex under a full complement of spray bottles, and its high walls keep tall bottles from leaning and toppling out mid-carry. It shrugs off bleach splashes and hoses out clean. It is the same basic design sold to janitorial services, which is exactly the durability standard a household caddy should meet.
- Key specs: Thick molded plastic construction, oversized center carry handle, high side walls, chemical-resistant finish, hose-out washable.
- What we like: Real load-bearing strength, walls tall enough for standard spray bottles, total indifference to chemical spills, and years of durability.
- What we do not like: No dividers, so small items like brushes and sponges tumble around loose, and it is bulkier than slim under-sink organizers.
- Who should buy it: Multi-room and multi-floor cleaners, and anyone who has already snapped the handle off a thin bargain caddy.
- Who should avoid it: People organizing a shallow under-sink cabinet in place, a divided low-profile caddy like the mDesign uses that space better.
- Common complaints: The lack of compartments is the recurring note, small tools slide around unless you add a cup or divider yourself.
- Size note: Measure your under-sink clearance including plumbing, the tall walls that protect bottles also need cabinet height to slide in.
- Cleaning note: Rinse it in a utility sink or shower every month or two, dried product rings wipe off the smooth plastic easily.
- Alternative: The mDesign Divided Cleaning Caddy is the choice if sorted compartments matter more than maximum carry strength.
Cleaning Caddy Buying Guide
Handle and wall strength first
A loaded caddy of full spray bottles weighs more than people expect, and thin plastic handles are the number one failure point. Look for a molded-in handle rather than a snapped-on one, and walls high enough that bottles cannot lean over the edge. If the caddy flexes when you squeeze it empty, it will fold when loaded.
Divided or open layout
Open bins carry big bottles best and clean easiest, while divided caddies keep brushes, sponges, and gloves from burying each other. If your kit is mostly sprays, go open like the Rubbermaid. If it is a mix of small tools and a few bottles, dividers earn their space. Some households do best with one of each.
Fit the cabinet, then the load
Measure under-sink height and depth around the plumbing trap before buying, tall caddies frequently do not clear the pipes. Chemical-resistant plastic is non-negotiable, bleach and degreasers stain and embrittle cheap materials. Skip fabric organizers for liquids entirely, one leak and they are ruined.
Safety Notes
- Store cleaning chemicals in their original labeled bottles, never decant into unlabeled containers in the caddy.
- Keep the caddy up high or behind a cabinet lock if children or pets are in the home.
- Do not store ammonia and bleach products pressed together, a double leak can mix them into toxic gas.
- Wipe up caddy spills promptly, residue on the handle transfers chemicals to bare hands.
What to Avoid
- Fabric caddies for liquid products, one leak soaks in permanently.
- Wire baskets, small bottles and brushes tip through the gaps.
- Thin bargain caddies with snap-on handles, they fail under a full load.
- Caddies taller than your under-sink clearance, measure around the plumbing first.
FAQ
What should go in a cleaning caddy?
An all-purpose spray, a bathroom cleaner, a glass cleaner, microfiber cloths, a scrub brush, a sponge, and gloves cover most homes. Keep specialty products like oven cleaner stored separately, the caddy works best as the grab-and-go kit for routine cleaning.
Is one caddy enough for a whole house?
For apartments and single-level homes, yes, one well-stocked caddy travels fine. Multi-floor households usually do better with a caddy per floor or one main caddy plus a small bathroom kit, which saves carrying weight up and down stairs.
How do I keep the caddy itself clean?
Empty it every month or two and rinse it with warm water and dish soap in a utility sink or shower. Molded plastic caddies like the Rubbermaid wipe clean in a minute, which is a real reason to avoid fabric organizers for chemical storage.
Final Verdict
The Rubbermaid Deluxe Carry Caddy is the best cleaning supplies organizer caddy, with the mDesign Divided Cleaning Caddy as the value pick for sorted storage and the Sterilite Divided Caddy covering budget under-sink organization.
