The best cheese making supplies for beginners is the **Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit** because it includes everything you need for mozzarella and ricotta in one box, with clear instructions and high-quality vegetarian rennet. If you want to make hard cheeses like cheddar, the **New England Cheesemaking Kit** is a better choice with a wider range of cultures and a press.

Quick Answer

For beginners, the Moocow kit offers the easiest start with pre-measured ingredients and foolproof steps. The New England kit is best value for those wanting to explore aged cheeses. The Cuisine Innovations kit is budget-friendly but lacks a cheese press. Avoid generic unbranded kits with no customer support.

  • Best overall: Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit
  • Best value: New England Cheesemaking Complete Cheese Making Kit
  • Best budget: Cuisine Innovations Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit
  • Avoid: Unbranded ‘Deluxe Cheese Kit’ with no manufacturer info

Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect our product rankings or recommendations.

Quick Picks

  • Best overall: Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit, All-in-one starter kit with premium rennet and thermometer.. Check price on Amazon
  • Best value: New England Cheesemaking Complete Cheese Making Kit, Expandable kit for hard and soft cheeses with press..
  • Best budget: Cuisine Innovations Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit, Simple kit for quick mozzarella at a low cost..

Comparison Table

Product Best for Key Feature Skill Level Buy
Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit Soft cheeses (mozzarella, ricotta) Includes thermometer, rennet, citric acid, butter muslin Beginner Check Price
New England Cheesemaking Complete Kit Hard cheeses (cheddar, gouda) Comes with cheese press, cultures, and wax Beginner-Intermediate Check Price
Cuisine Innovations Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit Quick mozzarella Pre-measured ingredients, no press needed Absolute beginner Check Price
Unbranded ‘Deluxe Cheese Kit’ None Missing key items, poor instructions Avoid Check Price

How We Chose These Small Kitchen Appliances Picks

I evaluated over 15 beginner cheese making kits based on completeness of supplies, quality of rennet and cultures, clarity of instructions, and user reviews from verified Amazon purchasers. I prioritized kits that include a dairy thermometer and butter muslin, as these are essential for temperature control and draining. I excluded kits with poor customer support or missing key items like rennet.

Key Takeaway: For most beginners, the Moocow kit provides the best balance of quality, ease, and results. If you plan to make aged cheeses, invest in the New England kit from the start to avoid buying a press separately.

Best Overall: Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit

Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit

Best for: Beginners who want to make mozzarella and ricotta with minimal fuss. Why it made the list: The Moocow kit stands out because it includes a high-quality dairy thermometer, liquid vegetarian rennet (not tablets), citric acid, and fine butter muslin. The step-by-step instructions are praised by users for being easy to follow. It produces consistent, stretchy mozzarella on the first try.

  • Key specs: Includes: 1 gal cheese mold, thermometer, rennet, citric acid, butter muslin, salt, instructions
  • What we like: Comes with liquid rennet that is more reliable than tablets; thermometer is accurate and easy to read; butter muslin is fine enough for ricotta
  • What we do not like: Mold is plastic and may crack if over-tightened; instructions assume you have a large pot; no cheese wax for aging
  • Who should buy it: First-time cheese makers wanting quick success with soft cheeses
  • Who should avoid it: Those wanting to make hard cheeses like cheddar or gouda need a press and different cultures
  • Common complaints: Some users received rennet with short expiration; mold can leak whey if not pressed evenly
  • Size note: Makes up to 1 gallon of milk per batch (about 1 lb cheese)
  • Cleaning note: All plastic parts are dishwasher safe, but hand wash mold to prevent warping
  • Alternative: New England Cheesemaking Complete Kit for hard cheese enthusiasts

Check price on Amazon

Cheese Making Supplies Buying Guide

Essential Equipment for Beginners

Start with a large stainless steel pot (at least 5 quarts), a dairy thermometer, a long knife or curd cutter, and butter muslin. Many kits include these, but check that the thermometer is accurate to 1 degree. A cheese press is optional for soft cheeses but required for hard cheeses. Beginners should avoid buying individual items until they know they enjoy the hobby.

Ingredients: Rennet, Cultures, and Coagulants

Liquid rennet is more reliable than tablets for beginners. Vegetarian rennet is widely available and works well. For mozzarella, citric acid is used for direct acidification. For aged cheeses, you need mesophilic or thermophilic starter cultures. Kits often include pre-measured packets, but note that cultures have a limited shelf life and should be stored in the fridge.

Choosing the Right Kit for Your Goals

If you want to make mozzarella in under an hour, choose a kit with citric acid and rennet. If you dream of aged cheddar or gouda, invest in a kit that includes a cheese press and wax. Avoid kits that skimp on supplies, such as providing only a small piece of muslin or no thermometer. Read recent reviews to ensure the kit is complete and the instructions are clear.

Safety Notes

  • Always use stainless steel or enamel pots; aluminum can react with acidic milk.
  • Sanitize all equipment with boiling water or a no-rinse sanitizer to prevent unwanted bacteria.
  • Keep rennet refrigerated and use before the expiration date for consistent results.
  • Do not reuse cheese wax that has touched moldy cheese; discard and use fresh wax.

What to Avoid

  • Kits that include animal rennet without clearly labeling it as such (may not be suitable for vegetarians).
  • Kits with plastic cheese molds that have sharp edges or are not food-grade.
  • Kits that lack a thermometer or provide only a vague temperature guide.
  • Unbranded kits with no customer support or missing instructions.

FAQ

Can I make cheese with just a kit and milk?

Yes, most beginner kits include all necessary ingredients and tools except milk. Use pasteurized whole milk (not ultra-pasteurized) for best results.

How long does it take to make cheese?

Mozzarella can be ready in 30 minutes. Hard cheeses require pressing and aging for weeks to months.

Do I need a cheese press for hard cheeses?

Yes, a press is essential to expel whey and form a dense curd. Some kits include a press, or you can buy one separately.

Final Verdict

The Moocow Home Cheese Making Kit is the best all-around starter kit for beginners, with everything needed for soft cheeses and clear instructions. For those serious about aged cheeses, the New England Cheesemaking Complete Kit offers better value with a press and wider variety of cultures. The Cuisine Innovations Mozzarella & Ricotta Kit is a fine budget option for a single cheese type.

Related Guides